Wednesday, 2 April 2025
26.8 C
Singapore
29 C
Thailand
20 C
Indonesia
26.6 C
Philippines

Misinformation researcher admits AI errors in court filing

Misinformation expert Jeff Hancock admits AI errors in a court filing, defends arguments, and regrets citation mistakes caused by ChatGPT.

A leading misinformation expert has admitted that he used ChatGPT to assist with drafting a legal document, which led to errors that critics say undermined the filing’s reliability. Jeff Hancock, founder of the Stanford Social Media Lab, acknowledged the mistakes but insisted they did not affect the document’s core arguments.

The case and the controversy

Hancockโ€™s affidavit was submitted to support Minnesota’s โ€œUse of Deep Fake Technology to Influence an Electionโ€ law, which is currently under challenge in federal Court. The law is being contested by Christopher Khols, a conservative YouTuber known as Mr. Reagan, and Minnesota state Representative Mary Franson. Their legal team flagged the filing, alleging that some of its citations didnโ€™t exist and calling the document โ€œunreliable.โ€

In response, Hancock filed a follow-up declaration admitting to using ChatGPT to help organise his sources. While he denies using the AI tool to write the document itself, he conceded that errors in the citation process were introduced due to the AIโ€™s so-called โ€œhallucinations.โ€

Hancockโ€™s defence

In his latest statement, Hancock defended the overall integrity of his filing. โ€œI wrote and reviewed the substance of the declaration, and I stand firmly behind each of the claims made in it,โ€ he said. He emphasised that his arguments were based on the most up-to-date academic research and reflected his expert opinion on how artificial intelligence influences misinformation.

Hancock explained that he used Google Scholar and GPT-4 to identify relevant research articles. While this process aimed to combine his existing knowledge with new insights, it inadvertently led to two non-existent citations and one with incorrect authors.

Regret but no intent to mislead

Hancock expressed remorse for the errors, stating, โ€œI did not intend to mislead the Court or counsel. I express my sincere regret for any confusion this may have caused.โ€ However, he firmly stood by the documentโ€™s main points, asserting that the errors do not diminish the substance of his expert opinion.

The incident highlights ongoing concerns about the risks of relying on AI tools in sensitive contexts. Although such tools can speed up research and drafting, they can also generate errors that compromise the credibility of the work they support.

As the legal challenge progresses, it remains unclear how the Court will view Hancockโ€™s affidavit and whether the acknowledged errors will impact the case.

Hot this week

ESET uncovers RansomHub links to rival gangs and highlights emerging EDR killer threats

ESET uncovers RansomHubโ€™s links to rival gangs and reveals its custom EDR killer, signalling new threats in the ransomware landscape.

MacBook Pro design overhaul expected in 2026

Apple might release a long-awaited MacBook Pro redesign in 2026, with OLED screens, improved portability, and more features.

Garmin launches premium Connect+ plan to boost health and fitness tracking

Garmin introduces Connect+ with AI insights, advanced training tools, and social features to help users reach their health and fitness goals.

New AI features coming to Final Cut Pro

Apple updates Final Cut Pro with AI-powered tools, Image Playground, and new features for Mac, iPad, and iPhone, enhancing video editing workflows.

Huawei reports 38% revenue surge as smartphone sales soar

Despite US sanctions, Huaweiโ€™s consumer business revenue surged 38% in 2024, driven by strong smartphone sales and home-grown chip production.

These robot vacuums are getting smarter with Apple Home support

Appleโ€™s iOS 18.4 update adds Matter support for robot vacuums, enabling control via Apple Home. Roborock, iRobot, and Ecovacs are updating their devices.

Gmail introduces easier encryption for business emails

Google introduces a new encryption model for Gmail, making it easier for businesses to send secure emails without special software or certificates.

Nothing Phone (3a) Pro review: A mid-range marvel with standout zoom

Nothing Phone (3a) Pro blends standout design, powerful zoom camera, and smart features, making it a top choice in the mid-range segment.

Vivo challenges iPhone 16 Pro Max with X200 Ultraโ€™s video stability

Vivoโ€™s X200 Ultra teaser compares video stability with the iPhone 16 Pro Max, promising top-tier camera upgrades and advanced stabilisation.

Related Articles