Thursday, 3 April 2025
26.1 C
Singapore
29.2 C
Thailand
27 C
Indonesia
27.3 C
Philippines

Figma pulls an AI tool after criticisms of copying Apple’s design

Figma pulled its AI tool Make Designs after criticism for copying Apple's iOS weather app, addressed issues, and revised its AI training policies.

Figma recently introduced an innovative tool named Make Designs that allows users to create app mockups quickly using generative AI. However, it faced significant backlash after producing designs resembling Appleโ€™s iOS weather app. As a result, Figma CEO Dylan Field announced the removal of Make Designs, attributing the issue to his push for the team to meet deadlines and defending the companyโ€™s approach to AI development.

Andy Allen, CEO of Not Boring Software, took to X to highlight the uncanny similarities between Figmaโ€™s Make Designs outputs and Appleโ€™s Weather app. โ€œJust a heads up to any designers using the new Make Designs feature: you might want to thoroughly check existing apps or heavily modify the results to avoid legal trouble,โ€ Allen advised.

In an interview on Tuesday, Figma CTO Kris Rasmussen addressed the controversy, clarifying that Figma did not train the AI models used for the tool. Instead, the generative AI features are powered by off-the-shelf models and a bespoke design system. โ€œWe did no training as part of the generative AI features,โ€ Rasmussen explained, noting that this issue stems from the third-party models and design systems they employed.

Rasmussen’s statements echoed his earlier comments on X, where he assured users that Make Designs needed to be trained on existing apps. He stated that Figma is investigating how the similarities result from the third-party models versus the design systems they commissioned.

Figma’s AI training policies

Field reiterated in his posts that the Make Designs feature was not trained on Figma content, community files, or app designs, dismissing accusations of improper data training. He acknowledged, however, that the need for more variability in the designs was a significant problem.

The AI models powering Make Designs are OpenAIโ€™s GPT-4 and Amazonโ€™s Titan Image Generator G1. If Figma had not trained its AI tools yet, it would have produced designs resembling Appleโ€™s apps, suggesting that OpenAI or Amazonโ€™s models may have been trained on Appleโ€™s designs. Neither OpenAI nor Amazon responded to requests for comment.

Rasmussen emphasised that Figma aims to be transparent about its AI training policies with users. Users have until August 15th to opt in or out of allowing their content to be used for Figmaโ€™s AI training. Starter and Professional plans are opted in by default, while Organisation and Enterprise plans are opted out.

Rasmussen hinted at future possibilities when asked if Figma plans to train its models. โ€œWe see opportunities to refine design workflows by training models to understand design in the context of Figma,โ€ he said. However, he assured me that any training would focus on general design patterns and specific Figma design concepts.

Addressing future issues

To prevent similar issues, Rasmussen detailed the steps Figma is taking to improve its processes. โ€œWeโ€™re reviewing our bespoke design system to ensure it meets our quality standards and has sufficient variation,โ€ he stated. Additionally, Figma plans to implement more rigorous checks before re-enabling Make Designs to align with their quality standards and values.

Rasmussen reminded me that Make Designs is still in its beta phase. โ€œBetas are inherently imperfect. As Dylan mentioned, we didnโ€™t catch this issue, but we should have,โ€ he admitted. Despite this setback, Figma expects to re-enable Make Designs soon, while other AI features remain available in beta for users on the waitlist.

Figmaโ€™s situation highlights the broader challenges tech companies face when integrating AI into creative tools. Adobe, for instance, had to reassure users it wouldnโ€™t use their work for AI training following backlash over service changes. Similarly, Meta had to adjust its AI labels after photographers complained about mislabeling real photos.

Hot this week

This tiny and affordable device upgrades any speaker with Wi-Fi streaming and hi-res audio

The Atonemo Streamplayer is a tiny, affordable device that adds Wi-Fi streaming and hi-res audio support to any speaker with a 3.5mm aux port.

Oracle Cloud launches new Compute E6 shapes powered by AMDโ€™s 5th Gen EPYC processors

Oracle Cloud boosts performance with new Compute E6 shapes powered by 5th Gen AMD EPYC processors, now available in key global regions.

Tenable reveals privilege escalation flaw in Google Cloud Run

Tenable uncovers a privilege escalation flaw in Google Cloud Run, exposing risks linked to inherited permissions and service interdependencies.

Facebook introduces friends-only feed to cut out algorithmic content

Facebookโ€™s new Friends tab removes algorithmic recommendations, letting you see only posts from friends. It is now rolling out in the US and Canada.

Intel remains on course for next-gen CPUs

Intel CEO Lip-Bu Tan confirms that next-gen CPUs, including Panther Lake and Nova Lake, remain on track, with Panther Lake arriving in 2025.

Qualcomm expands AI research with MovianAI acquisition

Qualcomm has acquired Vietnamese AI research firm MovianAI to boost its AI development in smartphones, PCs, and software-defined vehicles.

Roblox introduces new parental controls to enhance child safety

Roblox introduces new parental controls, allowing parents to block games, restrict friends, and monitor their childโ€™s activity for better safety.

Anthropic introduces Claude for Education, a new AI chatbot plan for universities

Anthropic launches Claude for Education, an AI chatbot plan for universities that offers advanced learning tools and administration support.

Exabeam introduces Nova, an agentic AI that boosts cybersecurity operations

Exabeam unveils Nova, a proactive AI agent that boosts security team productivity and reduces incident investigation time by over 50%.

Related Articles