Thursday, 24 April 2025
26.8 C
Singapore
29.9 C
Thailand
19.5 C
Indonesia
28.8 C
Philippines

Apple wins patent battle against Masimo, awarded US$250 in damages

Apple awarded US$250 in damages in a patent infringement case against Masimo, focusing on protecting innovation rather than financial gain.

In a recent patent dispute, Apple achieved a limited victory against medical device company Masimo over alleged patent infringements. On Friday, a federal jury ruled that Masimo had indeed infringed on some of Apple’s patents and, as a result, awarded Apple US$250 in statutory damages — a sum Apple requested as a symbolic gesture.

Apple secures symbolic victory with US$250 damages

The US$250 damages Apple received from this case represent the statutory minimum for the patent violations. Apple specifically requested this figure to emphasise that the case was not about financial compensation. During closing arguments, Apple’s attorney, John Desmarais, clarified this point to jurors, saying, “We’re not here for the money,” as reported by Bloomberg Law. By seeking the minimum damages, Apple underscored its focus on enforcing patent rights rather than seeking financial gain.

This lawsuit focused on a few Masimo products, including the W1 and Freedom smartwatches and an associated health module. The jury found that these products had violated one of Apple’s patents, while Masimo’s smartwatch charger infringed on another. The verdict also noted that Masimo’s infringement was “wilful,” indicating the jury believed the company knowingly violated Apple’s intellectual property.

Apple adjusts watch features after separate ITC ruling

This ruling follows a separate decision by the International Trade Commission (ITC) earlier this year, which concluded that Apple had itself infringed on Masimo’s patents relating to pulse oximetry, the technology used to measure blood oxygen levels. Due to that ITC ruling, Apple was forced to stop selling the Apple Watch Series 9 and Ultra 2 models with blood oxygen features in the United States. Consequently, the latest Apple Watch Series 10, which was recently launched, also lacks these features to comply with the ITC’s restrictions.

Apple’s legal battles with Masimo have highlighted the competitive nature of the wearable health-tech industry, where both companies are attempting to innovate while protecting their intellectual property. As the popularity of health-focused wearable devices continues to grow, disputes over patents and proprietary technologies are likely to become even more common. With Apple and Masimo actively investing in the health-monitoring market, this recent case could mark one of many future challenges as tech companies push to advance medical-grade wearable technology.

The ruling serves as a partial victory for Apple, underscoring the importance of protecting its innovations while only receiving a symbolic US$250 in damages. Whether further legal battles await Apple and Masimo in this ongoing rivalry remains to be seen, but both companies appear committed to maintaining their positions within the industry.

Hot this week

Meta’s Oversight Board asks for clarity on new hate speech rules

Meta’s Oversight Board is urging more transparency on hate speech policy changes and urging the company to protect vulnerable users.

Apple’s iPhone sales drop in China amid growing trade tensions

Apple’s iPhone sales in China fell 9% as local brands grew, and trade tensions created more uncertainty for the smartphone market.

Identity theft and document forgery pose rising fraud risks for APAC businesses

Businesses in APAC face rising fraud threats, with identity theft and document forgeries driving up costs and urging investment in smarter ID tools.

GameMax unveils Blade Concept ATX case with bold design and powerful features

GameMax launches the Blade Concept ATX case, which features a striking blade design, RGB lighting, and support for high-end liquid-cooled PC builds.

Judge says Google broke antitrust laws in adtech market

A judge ruled that Google broke antitrust laws in the ad tech market, possibly leading to a breakup or new restrictions on its advertising business.

POCO launches entry-level C71 smartphone in Singapore with premium features

POCO launches the budget-friendly C71 smartphone in Singapore, offering premium design, enhanced cameras, and smooth performance at S$109.

NVIDIA uses AI to address climate, wildlife and disaster risks

NVIDIA’s AI tools support climate action, wildlife monitoring, and disaster risk mitigation, with uses spanning sea, land, sky and space.

Netflix raises subscription prices in Singapore again

Netflix again raises subscription prices in Singapore, with new rates for all plans and extra member slots.

GameMax unveils Blade Concept ATX case with bold design and powerful features

GameMax launches the Blade Concept ATX case, which features a striking blade design, RGB lighting, and support for high-end liquid-cooled PC builds.

Related Articles

Popular Categories