Wednesday, 2 April 2025
24.1 C
Singapore
31.1 C
Thailand
21.9 C
Indonesia
26.8 C
Philippines

1,000 artists release a silent album in protest against UK copyright law changes

1,000 artists released a silent album to protest UK copyright law changes allowing AI to use their work without permission or payment.

The UK government is pursuing controversial plans to change copyright laws to attract more AI companies. Under these changes, AI developers would be allowed to train their models using online content created by artists without needing permission or providing payment unless the creators actively opt-out. Many musicians and artists are pushing back against this proposal.

On Monday, a group of 1,000 musicians took a stand by releasing a “silent album” to protest the planned policy changes. Titled Is This What We Want?, the album features contributions from music legends such as Kate Bush, Imogen Heap, Max Richter, and Thomas Hewitt Jones. It also includes co-writing credits from well-known names like Annie Lennox, Damon Albarn, Billy Ocean, The Clash, Mystery Jets, Yusuf / Cat Stevens, Riz Ahmed, Tori Amos, and Hans Zimmer.

However, this is not your typical charity album. Instead of music, the album features recordings of empty studios and silent performance spaces. This creative approach symbolises what artists believe will result from these law changesโ€”the loss of their rights and creative control over their work.

โ€œYou can hear my cats moving around,โ€ said Hewitt Jones, describing his contribution to the album. โ€œI have two cats in my studio who bother me all day when Iโ€™m working.โ€

The message behind the album is even clearer when you look at its 12-track listing. The song titles state that the British government must not legalise music theft to benefit AI companies.

A growing global concern

This silent album is just one of many protests taking place worldwide as artists fight against AI’s use of their work without consent. Similar movements are happening in the US and other countries, showing that this issue extends far beyond the UK.

Ed Newton-Rex, the organiser of this project, is also leading a broader campaign against AI companies using creative work without licensing. His petition, which calls for stronger protections, has been signed by over 47,000 writers, musicians, visual artists, and actors. Nearly 10,000 signatures were collected in the last five weeks after the UK government announced its AI strategy.

Newton-Rex has also been running a non-profit focused on ethical AI, certifying companies that do not scrape or train their systems on copyrighted work without permission. Having worked in music and AI, he understands both sides of the debate. He once founded Jukedeck, an AI-driven music composition platform that allowed users to generate original music. Jukedeck was later acquired by TikTok, where Newton-Rex continued working in AI-driven music services before moving on to other major tech companies like Snap and Stability AI.

Artists left without real options

The UKโ€™s proposed changes would require artists to opt-out if they do not want their work used for AI training. However, Newton-Rex argues that this system leaves artists in a difficult position, as there is no clear way to track whether AI companies use their work.

โ€œWe know that opt-out schemes are just not taken up,โ€ he said. โ€œThis will give 90% to 95% of peopleโ€™s work to AI companies. Thatโ€™s without a doubt.โ€

Some artists are now considering releasing their work in other countries where copyright protections may be stronger. Hewitt Jones, who once threw his keyboard into a harbour in Kent during an earlier protest (he later retrieved it, but it was broken), has mentioned Switzerland as a possible alternative for future releases.

With no clear solution in sight, many artists fear their work will be freely taken and used to train AI, undermining their ability to earn a living. As the UK government moves forward with its AI strategy, the music industryโ€™s silent protest is making a loud statement.

Hot this week

ASEAN+ leads in hybrid AI adoption as Lenovo report highlights top CIO priorities

ASEAN+ leads hybrid AI adoption as Lenovo study highlights GRC, GenAI and partnerships as key to long-term AI success.

China-aligned hacker group FamousSparrow resurfaces in cyberattacks

ESET finds China-linked hacker group FamousSparrow still active with upgraded tools, targeting institutions in the US, Mexico and Honduras.

Xbox titles lead PlayStation Store preorders

Xbox games dominate PS5 preorders, with Indiana Jones and Forza Horizon 5 leading sales, proving Microsoft's strategy works.

AI-generated Studio Ghibli art raises fresh copyright concerns

OpenAIโ€™s AI image tool sparks controversy after generating Studio Ghibli-style art, raising new copyright concerns. Legal experts weigh in.

Chinese investor questions commercial future of humanoid robots

Chinese venture capitalist Allen Zhu questions the commercial potential of humanoid robots, sparking debate amid rising AI investment in China.

These robot vacuums are getting smarter with Apple Home support

Appleโ€™s iOS 18.4 update adds Matter support for robot vacuums, enabling control via Apple Home. Roborock, iRobot, and Ecovacs are updating their devices.

Gmail introduces easier encryption for business emails

Google introduces a new encryption model for Gmail, making it easier for businesses to send secure emails without special software or certificates.

Nothing Phone (3a) Pro review: A mid-range marvel with standout zoom

Nothing Phone (3a) Pro blends standout design, powerful zoom camera, and smart features, making it a top choice in the mid-range segment.

Vivo challenges iPhone 16 Pro Max with X200 Ultraโ€™s video stability

Vivoโ€™s X200 Ultra teaser compares video stability with the iPhone 16 Pro Max, promising top-tier camera upgrades and advanced stabilisation.

Related Articles